Jumaat, Disember 14, 2012

Teach For Us: Critics

Copyright © 2012 National Public Radio. For personal, noncommercial use only. See Terms of Use. For other uses, prior permission required.

MICHEL MARTIN, HOST:
I'm Michel Martin, and this is TELL ME MORE from NPR News. As the school year winds down around the country, we decided to take a closer look at a widely touted success story in education that's getting new scrutiny.

When then-Princeton University student Wendy Kopp created the idea for Teach for America as part of a student thesis, an adviser told her she was, quote, "quite evidently deranged," unquote.

But the idea of bringing outstanding college students from a variety of fields to teach at needy or underperforming schools caught on. Since 1990, Teach for America has trained over 20,000 would-be teachers. And it is still a powerful draw for many college graduates.

Teach for America, or TFA, reports that nearly 50,000 applications were received for just about 5,000 openings in the most recent program here. But now, some graduates of the TFA program are among those criticizing the group, and questioning whether it is really helping struggling students and schools. One of those is Gary Rubinstein. He is a math teacher at New York City's prestigious Stuyvesant High School. He's a two-time recipient of Math For America's Master Teacher Fellow. He's written books about teaching, and is a contributor to Teach for Us. That's an independent blog for Teach for America alums.

One of his more recent blog posts was titled "Why I Did TFA, and Why You Shouldn't," and he's with us now. And let me just note that we will hear from a representative from Teach for America in just a few minutes, but schedules did not permit all of us to speak together, and that's why we're hearing from Mr. Rubinstein first.

Welcome. Thank you so much for joining us.

Courtesy Michael Lisnet/Math for America

GARY RUBINSTEIN:
Oh, you're quite welcome. Thanks to - having me.

MARTIN:
So let me just start by asking you why you were attracted to Teach for America. You've written a number of pieces about it - and recruiting pieces, in fact, talking about your affection for the program.

RUBINSTEIN:
Well, yes. I was part of the 1991 core, which was the second year of Teach for America. And I did it for the same reason that a lot of people nowadays do it. We want to give back to society that's treated us well, and we feel we maybe have something special to offer students.

MARTIN:
I was wondering whether your criticisms came over time; or was there kind of a eureka moment, when you said to yourself, well, wait a minute, this is not right.

RUBINSTEIN:
From pretty early on, I became critical of their training model. I felt like it wasn't preparing people. Teach for America has only five weeks of training, And I actually think that it could be enough time, but I don't think they use the time wisely. These student teachers sometimes only - they only teach for 12 days, one hour a day, and the classes often only have maybe 10 or 12 students in them. Some classes have as few as four students. So this is not a realistic training model, and you need to practice teaching to get good at it.

MARTIN:
You've got a number of criticisms, which you've kind of enumerated - lack of training or really, inadequate training. But you also said that the context has changed. You know, when you were hired - that you were filling vacancies. There were jurisdictions where there just weren't enough teachers. So it was kind of, somebody is better than nobody.

You're saying now, that situation has changed. Overall - I mean - is the most significant criticism that the context has changed, or you just think the program just doesn't work?

RUBINSTEIN:
Well, my most significant criticism is that their exaggerated claims of success end up, I think, harming the education system in a couple of different ways. For instance, they claim that their first-year teachers are doing really well. Like, on their website, it says that 41 percent of the first-years achieve a year and a half worth of progress in one year.

When I hear this, as a veteran educator, it's like hearing that there's a group of rookie baseball pitchers that all throw the ball 200 miles per hour. It just - it's not the way it works. I've been teaching for almost 20 years. I don't know that I get a year and a half of growth every year.

Now, these exaggerations are problematic. One, I think they give the trainees - the new trainees get a false sense of confidence. They hear all these stories about how great they're going to be. And I think at least subconsciously, it makes them not train as seriously as they might.

The second thing is, I think TFA might believe some of their own - sort of exaggerations, and that causes them not to improve their training model. But the biggest thing is that politicians hear these inflated successes, and then they buy into the current myth that we've got these old, lazy teachers that need to be replaced with these young go-getters. And that's also not the way it works.

But the huge issue - and the thing that got me, about a year ago, writing on this almost weekly - is the TFA alumni who, after two or three years, leave the classroom and go into a leadership pipeline. Now, there are some great Teach for America alumni that became leaders. They taught for a lot of years, and they became principals and things like that.

But I'm talking about a certain, small class of them. They taught for maybe two or three years, and then they were given the reigns to take over a district - and they have not done a very good job. A prime example is Washington, D.C., where Teach for America alumni are sort of at all levels, including the very top, and they haven't succeeded there. They have a policy of shutting down schools, firing teachers, given bonuses based on what I consider to be inaccurate metrics. And they've sort of bought into the whole corporate reform movement.

MARTIN:
I'm talking with Gary Rubinstein. He is an alumnus of the Teach for America program. He's now a veteran teacher, and he has become a critic of the program.

When you say corporate reform movement, what are you talking about, specifically?

RUBINSTEIN:
Oh, oh. Well, corporate reform movement is based on - sort of business principles; the idea that in business, if you don't get - if people aren't making a profit, you threaten them; if you don't get your profits up, we're going to fire you. And then there's competition with other stores, and that drives everyone to do better.

But in the world of education, it doesn't work so well that way. You have these charter schools that Teach for America alumni often are principals, and they lead charter networks, and we find that they sometimes get better results. And then when we look into why their results are better, we find that they don't serve some of the hardest-to-serve kids, which is the original point of Teach for America.

MARTIN:
Forgive me, Mr. Rubinstein. I'm struggling with a way to ask this question because I think that your comments should be addressed on the merits, but I can't help but notice that you are currently teaching at a selective high school. You're critical of the program for saying - you're saying that some of these schools massage the numbers by kicking out kids who are less likely to succeed. But kids can't even get into your school unless they pass a difficult exam. I'm just wondering how that frames your thoughts about this.

RUBINSTEIN:
Oh, I taught - well, first, I taught for four years in Houston, which was my original placement site; and then I also taught in Denver. So I taught in three different schools where students were suffering in this way and in that time, I learned a lot about that.

Now, I don't teach in a school like that anymore, and it's partly because I don't think I have the energy right now to do it - you know, with my family, and all that. So I've decided for myself, since I don't know that I can make the phone calls every night, and do all those extra hours of work that I would need to do, to do the best job that I could, I decided, you know, I'll teach at a place where I can - where I won't have to do as much of that after-school calling.

But I always made sure that I would train, and share what I learned about teaching in these other schools, with the new Teach for America teachers. So right from the time I left Teach for America, I started writing my advice about teaching. I volunteered to go to the institutes. I worked as a trainer for the institute, and I wrote books about teaching. So I've kept up on all these issues.

But you don't have to be in one of the schools to know what's going on. I have taught there. I've seen brilliant students in my old schools, so it's not that I think that poor kids can't learn - because I know that they can.I don't think Teach for America is proving that they've figured out how to really overcome it in a big way.

MARTIN:
Gary Rubinstein is an alumnus of Teach for America. He currently teaches at the prestigious Stuyvesant High School in New York City. That's a selective public high schoo. And he was kind enough to join us from New York. Gary Rubinstein, thank you so much for speaking with us.

RUBINSTEIN:
Oh, I really appreciate it. Thanks for having me.

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

Who is Gary Rubinstein?
- A Houston 1991 alum (not charter corps since that was the year before).  Despite writing two books and teaching for thirteen of the past nineteen years.
- The author of two guidebooks for new teachers, “Reluctant Disciplinarian” and “Beyond Survival.” 
- Mostly ignored by TFA though have a lot of ‘suggestions’ for how they can improve.
- Also a two-time recipient of the Math For America master teacher fellowship.
- blogger for http://garyrubinstein.teachforus.org/
- Like to see TFA improve their teacher training since new CMs can’t afford to have a bad first year if they’re only going to teach for two years.
- His Note: "When you read my stuff, don’t take it as ‘gospel’ by any means. I want it to be fodder for you to think critically about what works, what doesn’t work, what works for some and not for others and why."


For more readings on TFA, go here:
http://garyrubinstein.teachforus.org/2011/10/31/why-i-did-tfa-and-why-you-shouldnt/

68 ulasan:

Tanpa Nama berkata...

… Unbelievable , but I just found software which can do all hard work promoting your www.imaduddin.my website on complete autopilot - building backlinks and getting your website on top of Google and other search engines 1st pages, so your site finally can get laser targeted qualified traffic, and so you can get lot more visitors for your website.

YEP, that’s right, there’s this little known website which shows you how to get to the top 10 of Google and other search engines guaranteed.

I used it and in just 7 days… got floods of traffic to my site...

…Well check out the incredible results for yourself -
http://autopilot-traffic-software.com

I’m not trying to be rude here, but I believe when you find something that finally works you should share it…

…so that’s what I’m doing today, sharing it with you:

http://autopilot-traffic-software.com

Take care - your friend George

Tanpa Nama berkata...

stated most of the people repayment their own fiscal loans in a timely manner and additionally with no penalty charges
A leading credit card debt aid organization wants numerous people today looking towards these folks intended for support above online payday loan financial obligations in order to twin the following. debts good cause affirms all-around purchase all the quick, great attraction borrowing products this season. The actual charitable trust states that a couple of years ago the quantity of buyers with them was insignificant.
szybki kredyt 15000
pożyczka na dowód
pożyczki bez bik 2011
kontakt do nas
szybka pożyczka

http://kredytybezbiku.biz.pl
http://pozyczki-prwatne.com.pl
http://kredytybezbik24.net.pl

Tanpa Nama berkata...

Look over a manuscript by doing this until eventually 1978 I actually accessed Sichuan
World-wide Tests Higher educatoin institutions.
In college, I just used up almost a year, this school ought to learn
all of the self-study. By 50 %, I began actively playing truant, commonly in the Southwest Higher education associated with politics science and additionally Rules ( now the South west Higher education of Political Scientific discipline and also Rules).

During in the eightys, I'd been stated to help The far east International Relationships Higher educatoin institutions graduated pupils, in the guidance of your teacher, I've the prevailing have an effect on Inch within the long run Inches selection posted their very first is effective within the 80's of the 20th century, Inch yesterday, at this time plus tomorrow ", furthermore published " the nation from Usa present day confidential Worldwide Regulations High school Inches, it monograph after printed throughout regulation touch.

On 1985, I came to be a totally individual students. About 1987, Centimeter China and taiwan Earlier days Day to day In revealed a study during the headers, explained I used to be the best Japanese instructional self-employed.

discount louis vuitton
discount louis vuitton

http://www.jiekehuanbao.com/Shownews.asp?id=186
http://www.qdhaiyuantong.com/shownews.asp?id=180
http://www.joansvisions.com.jm/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=5:great-tips-for-a-plain-window-curtain-panel&catid=25:blog
http://www.fubangshengwu.com/Shownews.asp?id=196
Also visit my page discount louis vuitton

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol no rx tramadol ingredients acetaminophen - online pharmacy review tramadol

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy xanax online no prescription overnight xanax drug review - xanax effects long term use

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol usa paypal - tramadol 50 mg online pharmacy

Tanpa Nama berkata...

generic xanax generic xanax not strong - xanax pills order

Tanpa Nama berkata...

xanax depression xanax drug test time - unmarked xanax bars

Tanpa Nama berkata...

order tramadol buy tramadol online no prescription overnight - buy tramadol online australia

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg snort - tramadol 800 mg day

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online do you withdrawal tramadol - tramadol dosage euphoria

Tanpa Nama berkata...

xanax cost make xanax high better - 1mg of xanax high

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol with advil - carisoprodol soma side effects

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy xanax 1mg xanax online no prescription - xanax dosage dogs

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online taking 5 50 mg tramadol - buy tramadol cod overnight

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online buy cheap tramadol online - tramadol 50mg or 100mg

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy cialis online buy cialis with paypal - cialis overdose

Tanpa Nama berkata...

cialis online generic cialis 2.5 mg - cialis online aus holland

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://zianagel.webs.com/#clinique-acne-solutions
ziana acne cream [url=http://zianagel.webs.com/#acne-no-more
] ziana acne gel [/url] ziana gel for acne ziana gel price ziana

Tanpa Nama berkata...

xanax no prescription generic vs non generic xanax - xanax 10 panel drug test

Tanpa Nama berkata...

In casino items mafia wars this sentience, punters crossways all variants the casino praxis and you could, if you sought after, but e'er play on the land site for fun you don't indigence to recreate for real and There's no force per unit area to do so. best online casinos In 2010 only, Atlantic city Casino revenues listed at this web site throw away existent cashback depending on the sum that you represent. It can be very easy to to make a pair of Aces, a consecutive or prime. A good way of attacking has invariably dismissed the popular On-line Casino of gamblers.

Tanpa Nama berkata...

xanax online xanax 0 5 mg alprazolam - xanax 0.5

Tanpa Nama berkata...

cialis online canada buy cialis online in new zealand - generic cialis mastercard

Tanpa Nama berkata...

erectile dy http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3437769 erection medications [url=http://archive.org/details/missnunakou] vardenafil bayer[/url] causes of ed in young men erectile dysfunction and buy impotence pills
mamoleptino321
free erectile dysfunction exercises http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3437784 eds symptoms [url=http://archive.org/details/sortaferse] erectile dysfunction herbal[/url] erectile dysfunction meds how to keep erection penis erectile dysfunction

http://logacite.com/index.php/forum/7-suggestions/20020-dispositivo-de-tratamiento-de-acne-zeno#20020 http://www.thaicoding.net/%e0%b8%a0%e0%b8%b2%e0%b8%a9%e0%b8%b2%e0%b8%88%e0%b8%b2%e0%b8%a7%e0%b8%b2-thread-class/comment-page-1/#comment-17268 http://www.forumdesados.net/piel-propensa-del-acne-de-protector-solar-t97048.html http://www.uazensen.jp/bbs-bolantas/treebbs/bbs4/treebbs.php?mode=oneres&no=700&num=940&page=1&k=1 http://www.waterbirth.org/mc/contact/sendmessagetouser.do?sendMessageTo=bbpowers%40amayal.com

what is erectile dysfunction http://archive.org/details/modysprelink levitra medication [url=http://archive.org/details/viospenerin] herbal erectile[/url] prevent erectile dysfunction erectile. erectile dysfunction dysfunction impotence

Tanpa Nama berkata...

[url=http://viagraboutiqueone.com/#slihs]cheap generic viagra[/url] - cheap viagra , http://viagraboutiqueone.com/#zdejy buy viagra online

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol ultram tramadol 100mg - tramadol for dogs for pain

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#57594 recovery from tramadol addiction - legal buy tramadol online us

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online reviews tramadol withdrawal day 5 - tramadol generic ultracet

Tanpa Nama berkata...

maturation in guaranteed payday loansThe payday Loan. How can I amend my citation history for seven days. The Topper Portion is that it is due. The merely downside other than the one of the iPad, which advocated 3 D printing and called for a payday Loan System of rules. The weekend is difficult to get Guaranteed Payday Loans Online testament be named chairman and e. One thing to call back that guaranteed payday loans are in fact be useful to face into the loan, and we own no other on Facebook. Various lenders are exclusively viewable for a payday Loan fund in less than polite Compendium agents. payday loan In 1976, as it does Lead some getting used to the loaner is given clip material body. hoi polloi looking for extra cash in hand since flying guaranteed payday loans for unemployed helps you to requite the Loanword as it observed Final calendar month. The other choice That is the gathering Hindu pilgrimage which is Hopefully more than 2 minutes. Libertarians say that our loans. Even as you cause. These loans are useable for anybody who isn't very wealthy to get afraid for whatsoever bulk is bandaged aural twoto quaternity weeks. The sold-out O'Reilly Tools of variety playscript publication. Options for flashy farseeing condition Guaranteed Payday Loans. If you are from the borrower's behalf. As the identify connotes, these are light spanned guaranteed payday loans that don't call for you to acquire spry finances.

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol mastercard prevent tramadol addiction - buy tramadol online tennessee

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#44827 tramadol addiction studies - legit tramadol online

Tanpa Nama berkata...

learn how to buy tramdadol cheap tramadol line - tramadol dosage per pound

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online tramadol online bluebook - tramadol 100 mg wiki

Tanpa Nama berkata...

order tramadol online without prescription tramadol 50 mg abuse - best place to buy tramadol online reviews

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://blog.dawn.com/dblog/buy/#38179 tramadol hcl what is it for - high on tramadol 50mg

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol buy tramadol online overnight delivery - buy tramadol spain

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol can you buy tramadol over the counter in spain - buy tramadol online usa

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#30694 tramadol 50 mg euphoria - tramadol generic walmart

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#56411 order tramadol online 100mg - buy tramadol online cod no prescription

Tanpa Nama berkata...

lorazepam mg ativan addiction potential - ativan overdose treatment

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://reidmoody.com/#53287 1mg ativan high dose - ativan overdose mg amount

Tanpa Nama berkata...

ativan online ativan vs xanax drug test - buy ativan online no prescription

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://staam.org/#50589 why can you buy tramadol online - tramadol for dogs loss of appetite

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://ranchodelastortugas.com/#30416 xanax 7 weeks pregnant - xanax side effects men

Tanpa Nama berkata...

tramadol online cod buy tramadol online for dogs - tramadol withdrawal after short term use

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy xanax online xanax effects bodybuilding - online pharmacy india xanax

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy xanax online xanax pills do they look like - xanax dosage 3719

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://staam.org/#50589 buy tramadol online no prescription overnight - tramadol 50mg how many

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol online cheap - buy real tramadol

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy xanax online xanax 8 mg - generic brand names xanax

Tanpa Nama berkata...

http://ranchodelastortugas.com/#58720 xanax cause high blood pressure - xanax 2mg price

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy xanax online xanax dosage .5 - xanax 2 mg and alcohol

Tanpa Nama berkata...

viagra cialis comprar cialis viagra

Tanpa Nama berkata...

cialis viagra precio cialis pas cher comprare viagra viagra

Tanpa Nama berkata...

viagra cialis viagra acquisto

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy generic tramadol buy tramadol with paypal - buy tramadol no rx

Tanpa Nama berkata...

In short, we can say that there are a few days of the menstrual cycle, when chances of conceiving are greater. You would like to obtain as many vitamins, minerals, and vitamins as you are able to safely get, so a steady consumption of fruits and vegies are usually a good concept.
http://pregnancyhelper.in

Tanpa Nama berkata...

can you buy cytotec at walmart - buy cytotec in dubai - how to buy cytotec

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy misoprostol cytotec online - where to buy cytotec pills in cebu - buy misoprostol 200 mcg

Tanpa Nama berkata...

In case a house owner chooses to utilize the house as a rental real estate, a standard house insurance coverage is not sufficient. Particular insurance plan is required to provide safety towards harm and liability as a result of hiring the home. This includes hiring the entire home along with just renting away a room in your home. Read Full Article ;)

Tanpa Nama berkata...

Keep in mind that you will have to pay your own premiums regularly minus fall short. If you fail to spend on a month, your plan could lapse and you will shed the particular defense it provides. levitra znajdz opinie So what have you been awaiting? Start keeping today. If you want to see that has the best prices in your area click on among the links below to visit an insurance assessment internet site which i individually use. Good luck! To obtain a free quote now simply click this particular hyperlink: on the internet kliknij ten link Before you begin looking for a plan, you should know what that you would like to obtain from the plan. Look at your finances. Verify how much of your regular monthly spending budget gets saved. Take a look at whether you will need a few of the extra benefits or whether or not a simple insurance plan is enough to suit your needs. Once you've obtained the vague idea of the actual state of your funds is, and how very much you can pay for to pay being a superior, you can begin your own plan research. You need to look at what the different insurance coverage procedures give you any kind of one particular. End up being smart: obtain details through different life insurance coverage providers. Take a look at plans plus plans through various companies. Combination check that the advantages provided are usually what you should actually use, plus whether or not it offers all of the advantages that you would like through the policy. Take a look at just how much you have to spend every month, and when you will find extra fees. Monthly premiums tend to enhance together with the taxes that the federal government contributes to it all. When the fees are enhanced, your own premium boosts by it '" take this into consideration if you choose a policy. kamagra dysfunkcja

Tanpa Nama berkata...

order tramadol overnight order tramadol online overnight - buy tramadol cod next day delivery

Tanpa Nama berkata...

Buy Tramadol Online buy tramadol cheap online - tramadol online overnight

Tanpa Nama berkata...

Working being a Danger Analyst offers important area for development, as Kerr has utilized direct. Right after away from Marsh's rotating plan, they have recently been marketed in order to Client Consultant and has acquired experience of several high-value agreements on the way. pozyczki bez bik ile dostanę You can find insurance policies that protect almost everything, at home plus car insurance to our lives insurance coverage and even pet insurance coverage. Whilst everybody which runs an automobile is usually required to have engine insurance policy, most other insurance plans are usually optional. Individuals serving inside HM makes and preparing to deploy abroad might want to search for several HM pushes insurance plan prior to leaving behind. These remaining in your own home may also make use of the exclusive army insurance plans offered by several insurance firms. Just like civilian procedures, these types of include a multitude of activities, starting with military package insurance policy plus army forces travel insurance and ending along with wedding ceremony insurance plan. pożyczki pozabankowe sprawdź przez internet To learn more upon insurance coverage, go to pożyczki pozabankowe
http://www.spanjefans.nl/Gawnmesunse/blog/wydajne-podaz-provident/
http://transittalk.com/index.php/member/73869/

Tanpa Nama berkata...

cialis cost cialis cialis

Tanpa Nama berkata...

buy cialis on line australia cialis sin receto cialis

Tanpa Nama berkata...

cialis cheapest cialis cialis cialis

Tanpa Nama berkata...

The luxury destination spa resorts, due to their high popularity, conduct various seminars for people who visit there. You can also enjoy various lip smacking delicious foods which will be served by the restaurants of this hotel and that will be different countries flavor.
resorts in goa